Conversation between a Sage and an Unenlightened Man

WND Volume 1 · Read on Nichiren Library →

Background

Written To

Unknown samurai - someone of the warrior class who carried bow and arrows

When

1265, during political upheaval and natural disasters in Japan

Why It Was Written

The recipient was struggling with the impermanence of life after witnessing many deaths during the Shōka era, seeking Buddhist teachings to understand how to free himself from suffering

Significance

This writing systematically refutes the four major Buddhist schools of Nichiren's time and establishes the Lotus Sutra as the supreme teaching, serving as a comprehensive guide for distinguishing correct from incorrect Buddhism

Key Passages

"Rely on the Law and not upon persons. Even when great bodhisattvas such as Universal Worthy and Manjushrī expound the Buddhist teachings, if they do not do so with the sutra text in hand, then one should not heed them."

Nichiren emphasizes that we must judge teachings by their content and scriptural basis, not by how impressive or popular the teacher is. Even the most revered religious figures can lead us astray if their teachings contradict the Buddha's actual words in the sutras.

"In the past I sat upright in the place of meditation for six years under the bodhi tree... But in these more than forty years, I have not yet revealed the truth."

This quote from the Buddha himself admits that for over forty years of teaching, he was using provisional methods suited to people's limited capacity. Only in the Lotus Sutra did he finally reveal his true intention - that all people can become Buddhas.

"Honestly discarding expedient means, I will preach only the unsurpassed way."

The Buddha declares in the Lotus Sutra that he's setting aside all the temporary teachings he used before and will now teach the direct path to enlightenment. This passage shows that clinging to earlier Buddhist schools is like preferring elementary lessons when the advanced course is available.

"When one chants Nam-myoho-renge-kyo, the Buddha nature inherent in all things will be summoned forth, and one's own Buddha nature will simultaneously emerge."

This reveals the practical essence of Nichiren's teaching - that simply chanting the title of the Lotus Sutra awakens the enlightened life condition within ourselves and connects us with the Buddha nature in everything around us, regardless of our level of Buddhist scholarship.

What This Writing Is Really Saying

Nichiren's fundamental message is that in our confused age, we need to rely on the correct Buddhist teaching to avoid falling into spiritual dead ends. He systematically shows how the popular Buddhist schools of his day - focused on precepts, calling on Amida Buddha, esoteric rituals, or Zen meditation - are all based on provisional teachings that the Buddha himself said were temporary expedients.

The heart of the matter is this: the Buddha taught different things to different people over his 50-year teaching career, like a skilled doctor prescribing different medicines for different illnesses. But in his final and most important teaching, the Lotus Sutra, he revealed that all people - regardless of gender, social status, or past karma - possess the Buddha nature and can become enlightened. This was his true intention all along.

Nichiren argues that simply chanting Nam-myoho-renge-kyo (devotion to the Lotus Sutra) is the most direct way to awaken this Buddha nature within ourselves. Unlike complex meditation practices or moral disciplines, this practice is accessible to everyone and works by harmonizing our life with the fundamental rhythm of the universe itself.

The writing also addresses a crucial human dilemma: how do we choose between conflicting authorities? Nichiren's answer is to rely on documented evidence (what the Buddha actually said in the sutras) rather than on popular opinion, charismatic teachers, or social pressure. Truth isn't determined by majority vote or by how impressive someone's credentials are.

How This Applies to Your Life Today

This teaching is incredibly relevant for anyone trying to navigate today's overwhelming flood of self-help advice, spiritual teachings, and lifestyle philosophies. Just as the samurai was confused by contradictory Buddhist teachers, we face countless experts promising the secret to happiness through everything from mindfulness apps to life coaches. Nichiren's principle of 'rely on the Law and not upon persons' suggests we should judge any teaching by its actual results and logical consistency, not by the teacher's charisma or social media following.

In practical terms, this means developing our own inner compass for truth rather than constantly seeking external validation. When facing major life decisions - career changes, relationships, health challenges - we can chant Nam-myoho-renge-kyo to tap into our deepest wisdom rather than endlessly polling friends or scrolling through advice online. The practice helps us access what Nichiren calls our 'Buddha nature' - that inner strength and clarity that knows what's right for our specific situation.

The teaching about provisional versus true teachings also applies to how we approach personal growth. Many people get stuck cycling through different therapies, diets, or spiritual practices without ever committing deeply to one path. Nichiren suggests that once we find a practice that addresses the fundamental question - how to become truly happy and help others do the same - we should stick with it rather than constantly seeking the next new thing.

Read the Full Writing

This is a simplified explanation. For the complete text, visit the Nichiren Library.

Read Full Text on Nichiren Library →

← Back to all decoded writings