Why Present-Day Nembutsu Practitioners Are Destined for the Hell of Incessant Suffering

WND Volume 2 · Read on Nichiren Library →

Correct TeachingWisdomFaithLotus SutraDeath

Background

Written To

Jōen-bō, a priest at Renge-ji temple who had witnessed Nichiren's first declaration of his teaching in 1253 but had not yet become his disciple, though he respected Nichiren and his teachings

When

1264, about 50 days before the Komatsubara Persecution, during a period of intense religious conflict in Japan

Why It Was Written

Japan was dominated by Pure Land Buddhism (Nembutsu practice), which taught people to abandon all other Buddhist teachings including the Lotus Sutra. Nichiren was challenging this popular movement by pointing out contradictions between Pure Land promises and actual results

Significance

This writing demonstrates Nichiren's method of refuting erroneous teachings through careful analysis of texts and observable evidence, establishing the foundation for his assertion that only the Lotus Sutra can lead to true enlightenment

Key Passages

"At first ignorant and unwise people throughout Japan, both members of the clergy and lay believers, and then everyone, like grass bowing before a great wind, began to heed this advice of Hōnen, setting aside the joyful acceptance with which they had earlier embraced the Lotus Sutra or the True Word teachings."

Nichiren describes how Pure Land Buddhism swept through Japan like a powerful wind, causing people to abandon their faith in the Lotus Sutra and other Buddhist teachings. He's pointing out how easily people can be swayed by popular religious movements, even when it means giving up practices that brought them joy and benefit.

"The Reverend Shan-tao has stated categorically that of ten believers in the Nembutsu, ten will surely attain rebirth, that they are certain to gain rebirth in the Pure Land. There should be no doubt about the matter. Therefore if, of ten such persons, nine attain rebirth but one fails to do so, we are entitled to question the truth of his assertion."

Nichiren uses logical reasoning to challenge Pure Land claims. If their teaching promises 100% success but the evidence shows otherwise, then we have every right to question whether the teaching is true. He's encouraging people to think critically about religious promises versus actual results.

"We hear reports and learn that such outstanding leaders of the Nembutsu school as Zenne, Ryūkan, Shōkō, Sasshō, Namu, and Shinkō all succumbed to severe illnesses such as outbreaks of evil sores and in their final hour died in a state in which their minds were crazed and disordered!"

Rather than dying peacefully as promised, even the most devoted Pure Land practitioners suffered terrible deaths with confused, agonized minds. This concrete evidence contradicts the Pure Land promise of peaceful rebirth and suggests something is fundamentally wrong with the teaching.

"To persons whose capacity fitted them for the true teaching he offered the provisional doctrines. He took a country suited for the pure and perfect teaching and made it a country of the provisional teachings. It was as though, to persons accustomed to the flavor of ghee, he offered mere curdled milk or butter."

Nichiren argues that Hōnen gave people inferior teachings when they were actually capable of receiving the highest Buddhist wisdom. It's like offering cheap food to people who could appreciate and benefit from gourmet cuisine - a tragic waste of human potential.

What This Writing Is Really Saying

Nichiren is making a powerful case that we must judge religious teachings not by their popularity or promises, but by their actual results. When Pure Land Buddhism swept through Japan, it promised easy salvation through chanting Amida Buddha's name while telling people to abandon all other Buddhist practices, especially the Lotus Sutra. But when Nichiren looked at what actually happened to devoted Pure Land practitioners, he found the opposite of what was promised - instead of peaceful deaths and rebirth in paradise, even the most sincere practitioners suffered agonizing deaths with confused, tormented minds.

The deeper issue Nichiren identifies is that people are being offered second-rate teachings when they're capable of much more. He argues that the Japanese people have the capacity for the highest Buddhist teaching - the Lotus Sutra - which reveals that all people possess Buddha nature and can achieve enlightenment in this lifetime. But instead, they're being told they're too weak and corrupted for such 'difficult' practices, and must rely entirely on Amida Buddha's power. This creates a tragic situation where people abandon their own Buddha nature and inner strength.

Nichiren's message is ultimately about human dignity and potential. He refuses to accept that people in his era are somehow inferior to those in the Buddha's time, or that they need to wait for salvation in some distant paradise. Instead, he insists that every person has the same enlightened nature as the Buddha and can tap into that power through correct Buddhist practice. The evidence he presents - comparing the deaths of Pure Land practitioners with those who maintained faith in the Lotus Sutra - supports his conviction that only teachings that awaken our inherent Buddha nature can truly transform our lives and deaths.

How This Applies to Your Life Today

This writing teaches us to be discerning consumers of spiritual and self-help teachings. Just as Nichiren questioned Pure Land Buddhism's promises by examining actual results, we should evaluate any philosophy or practice by its real-world outcomes, not just its marketing claims. If a teaching promises transformation but its long-term practitioners show no evidence of genuine growth or peace, that's a red flag. We can apply this same analytical approach to business methodologies, therapeutic approaches, or lifestyle philosophies.

Nichiren's deeper point about human potential is especially relevant today. Many modern approaches to personal growth essentially tell us we're broken and need external fixes - whether that's the right medication, the perfect relationship, the ideal job, or the right spiritual teacher to save us. But Nichiren's Buddhism suggests we already possess everything we need for genuine happiness and contribution. Rather than looking outside ourselves for salvation, we can develop our inherent wisdom and strength through correct practice. This doesn't mean we don't need guidance or community, but that we approach them from a position of inner dignity rather than dependence.

Read the Full Writing

This is a simplified explanation. For the complete text, visit the Nichiren Library.

Read Full Text on Nichiren Library →

← Back to all decoded writings